… this post is more or less to make sound less like a hater. i am not going to take the easy route and dismiss 29er’s as trendy because its here to stay for sure and lets face it, i can be a trendy guy ( i love fixed gear bikes and ridgid single speed mountain bikes, tight britches and teeshirts from american apparel)
reason #1: i’m 5′5″ and although i claim 5′6″ just because you wont challenge me there is no feasable way for me to fit on one of these bikes.
maybe thats really all there is to it, but i like to be over the front.
reason #2: bottom bracket drop. i am kind of a bike geometry nerd… so some of you might know of this measurement as BB higth rather than drop. although the higth is relative to that of a 26er the drop is the important measurement being the distance between the plane of your axles and the bb spindle.
the more that distance increases the farther your feet get away from the center of the turning point as the bike leans gives you *less* traction in turns counter that by using a higher BB and you loose standover, and wind up witha bike that handles nervous.
*this is theoretical and can also be countered by the fact that a 29″ tire has more contact with the ground
reason #3: weight.
29ers are more heavy. so are their longer forks and longer rear triangles. oh and the rotational weight of the massive wheels
reason #4: rear end length.
think 1×9 is just a cool thing to do? most 29ers that are geared are 1×9 because front deraileur cages want to fight with tire knobs when typical geometry is used. otherwise they are lengthy wich means *less* traction and makes it harder to weight the rear tire on decents wich results in *less* controll
reason #5: head tube higth.
i have seen even normal sized riders put ugly inverted stems on their 29ers to get those bars lower!
reason #6: asthetics.
i know its petty, i just dont like the way they look.
i think most people who give it a try experiance a new feeling, and associate new with good… but i know several people from racers to weekend warriors who for waht ever reason got back on their 26er decided that they had been suckered into the 29 hype.
now talk amongst your selves and leave me comments telling me about how i am wrong.